Board Information

How to Choose a Community Management Company: A Guide for HOA and Condo Boards

How do you choose the right community management company?

The right community management company matches your association’s size, community type, and goals, and backs a strong local manager with an experienced support team. Boards should evaluate five factors: experience and credentials, services, financial controls, reputation, and communication and technology. Whether your board is reviewing a single firm or sending a request for proposal (RFP) to several, comparing every candidate against the same criteria leads to a better, more defensible decision.

1. Experience and credentials

Look for a company with a proven track record managing communities similar to yours in size, type (HOA, condominium, master-planned), and complexity. Ask about the qualifications of the manager who will be assigned to your community. Industry credentials from Community Associations Institute (CAI), such as the CMCA®, AMS®, and PCAM® designations, show a manager’s commitment to professional standards and ongoing education.

2. Services and resources

Every community has unique needs, so confirm the company can tailor its services to yours. Core services typically include:

  • Financial management, budgeting, and assessment collection
  • Covenant and violation enforcement
  • Board meeting preparation and support
  • Vendor management and maintenance coordination
  • Homeowner and board communication

Many firms also offer board education, developer and transition services, and online portals. Ask which services are included in the base fee and which cost extra.

3. Financial controls and fraud protection

Your association’s funds deserve the same safeguards as any business. Ask how the company separates accounting, collections, and accounts payable duties, whether operating and reserve funds are kept in separate accounts, and whether the firm undergoes annual independent audits. Third-party credentials, such as the Accredited Management Organization® (AMO) designation from the Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM), offer independent verification of a firm’s financial and ethical standards.

4. Reputation and references

Request references from communities the company currently manages and, if possible, from communities it has managed in the past. Read online reviews and ask current clients about responsiveness, transparency, and how problems are handled. A reputable company welcomes questions about its services, financial operations, and client satisfaction.

5. Communication and technology

Clear, consistent communication is the foundation of effective community management. Ask how quickly the company responds to board and homeowner inquiries and how it handles emergencies after hours. Evaluate its technology, including online portals for boards and residents, online payments, maintenance request tracking, and document access. The right tools save time and build trust across the community.

Questions to ask a community management company

  • How many communities like ours do you manage, and how many communities will our manager oversee?
  • What credentials does our assigned manager hold?
  • What is included in the management fee, and what costs extra?
  • How do you protect association funds from fraud?
  • How often will our manager visit the community?
  • What is your response time for board and homeowner inquiries?
  • What does your onboarding and transition process look like?

Why boards choose Sentry Management

Sentry Management is an AMO®-accredited firm that combines local expertise with national strength. Every Sentry-managed community is backed by the Sentry Promises: Reliable Communication, Great Meetings, Community Presence, Vendor Coordination, On-Time Financial Reporting, and Simplified Technology. These aren’t aspirations; they’re accountabilities we deliver every month.

Is Sentry the right fit for your community? Request a Proposal · Talk to a Local Sentry Manager

Share This Article

Serving on a board?

Sentry's board education program helps volunteers lead with confidence.

Explore Board Education

Ready to Talk?

Is Sentry the Right Fit for Your Community?

Talk to a Sentry representative — no obligation, no pressure. Just a real conversation about what your community needs to thrive.

Request a Proposal